ILLINOIS - IL
Illinois homeowners insurance: cost, the FAIR Plan and your rights at renewal
Illinois homeowners pay a published average of $2,174 a year on a $300,000 dwelling basis (Bankrate, 2025), against a $2,470 national figure. What sets Illinois apart is less the price than the rulebook: renewal protections that grow after five years with the same insurer, a claims regulation that measures delay in calendar days, and a FAIR Plan law being rewritten for 2027.
Published average
$2,174
Per year, about $181 a month.
National average
$2,470
12% lower in IL.
Median home value
$254,128
2023, context only.
Source year 2025, verified 2026-11-01; source named below. Benchmark, not a quote.
The Illinois FAIR Plan, and the change coming January 1, 2027
The Illinois FAIR Plan Association is where homeowners turn when the regular market will not insure them. Section 522 of the Illinois Insurance Code, in the text in force through 2026, gives the plan an explicit aim: to deter insurers from geographically redlining urban areas, to offer homeowners insurance to all citizens on a reasonable access basis, to bind eligible risks immediately and to allow installment payment of premiums.
Public Act 104-645 rewrites that purpose with effect from January 1, 2027. The new text drops the redlining language and describes an association of insurers that offers basic property insurance to qualified applicants. The same act tightens the notice rule in section 143.22: when an insurer cancels or nonrenews a fire and extended coverage policy for any reason other than unpaid premium or arson evidence, its notice must tell you that you may be eligible for the FAIR Plan, and from 2027 it must also print the plan's mailing address, website and phone number.
Nonrenewal: the five-year line
The Illinois Department of Insurance (IDOI) splits nonrenewal rules by how long your policy has been continuously in force. Under five years, an insurer can decline to renew for almost any reason on at least 30 days' mailed notice. At five years or more, 30 days' notice is allowed only when you obtained the policy with misleading or incorrect information, or when a significant change has made a loss measurably more likely; for every other reason the insurer must mail notice 60 days ahead.
Some reasons are off limits at any length of tenure: the age or location of the property, and the age, gender, race, color, ancestry, marital status or occupation of the people living there. Credit information alone cannot justify a nonrenewal, and since January 1, 2003 a claim for a loss that police identify as a hate crime cannot be the sole reason either. When the reason is declining property condition, you get up to 90 days to make the repairs. A notice must state the factual reason, not just the word fraud or misrepresentation. If you think the insurer broke these rules, a written hearing request must reach IDOI at least 20 days before the expiration date.
Cancellation during the policy term
In the first 60 days an Illinois insurer can cancel for nearly any reason. After 60 days, or once the policy has renewed, the permitted grounds shrink to nonpayment, misrepresentation or fraud, and an increase in the risk the insurer originally accepted. Notice is 10 days for nonpayment and 30 days for anything else.
How Part 919 measures claim delays
Illinois writes its claim standards into 50 Ill. Adm. Code Part 919. Section 919.50 requires an insurer to affirm or deny liability within a reasonable time and to offer payment within 30 days after affirming liability once the amount is settled; undisputed portions with a known payee must be paid within those 30 days too. If a homeowners claim is paid at less than you asked or denied, the written explanation, naming the policy language relied on and the availability of IDOI, is due within 30 days after the investigation ends.
Section 919.80 adds numbers specific to fire and extended coverage policies, the category homeowners policies fall into. Delay is presumed unreasonable when an insurer's median payment period on these claims exceeds 40 calendar days. If your claim is still unresolved 75 calendar days after you reported it, or 25 days after the insurer received your proof of loss, whichever comes first, the insurer owes you a written explanation of the delay. On an actual cash value settlement you can ask for the worksheet showing every depreciation deduction, and section 143.1 of the Insurance Code pauses the policy's deadline to sue from the day you file proof of loss until the day of denial.
Illinois questions
How much notice must an Illinois insurer give before nonrenewing my home?
At least 30 days if the policy has been in force under five years. After five years, 60 days, unless the reason is misrepresentation or a significant increase in risk, which allow 30 days.
Can an Illinois insurer drop me because of my credit?
Not based solely on credit report information. If credit data is used, the insurer must name the credit bureau so you can get a free copy of your report.
What is the Illinois FAIR Plan?
The state's association of property insurers that offers basic property and homeowners insurance to people who cannot find cover elsewhere. Its governing law is rewritten from January 1, 2027 by Public Act 104-645.
How long can an Illinois insurer take on a homeowners claim?
Payment is due within 30 days after liability is affirmed. If a claim is unresolved after 75 days from reporting, or 25 days after proof of loss, the insurer must explain the delay in writing.
How do I appeal a nonrenewal in Illinois?
Mail or deliver a written hearing request to the Illinois Department of Insurance at least 20 days before your policy expires, explaining why you believe the nonrenewal was improper.
Sources and check dates
- Illinois Department of Insurance, If your homeowners insurance policy is non-renewed, checked October 22, 2026.
- Illinois Department of Insurance, If your homeowners insurance policy is canceled, checked October 22, 2026.
- 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.50, checked October 22, 2026.
- 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80, checked October 22, 2026.
- 215 ILCS 5/522, FAIR Plan purpose (before and after P.A. 104-645), checked October 22, 2026.
- 215 ILCS 5/143.22, FAIR Plan eligibility notice, checked October 22, 2026.
- 215 ILCS 5/143.1, limitation periods tolled, checked October 22, 2026.