BENCHMARK TOOL

Home Cover Benchmark

Pick a state, a home-value band, a roof age, and a deductible. We start from the published state average we cite, apply simple adjustment factors printed below, and show a benchmark range. Labeled clearly: this is a benchmark range from published averages, not a quote for your home.

Disclaimer: Published averages and ranges, not a quote. This page is not insurance advice. Your premium will differ based on your home, location, claims history, and insurer.

Suburban home under a clear sky after a storm, illustrative photo
Illustrative photo. After the weather clears, the useful question is whether your quote sits inside a normal range for your state and dwelling limit.

Example: replace with your home and renewal. The tool opens on California, a $300k dwelling band, a roof aged 10-20 years and a $1,000 flat deductible, so you can see how it works. Change every field to your own before you judge a real quote.

Saved on this device only. Your entries are stored in this browser on this device, never sent to us.

Benchmark range: $1,581 to $2,470 per year

This is a benchmark range from published averages, not a quote for your home. Base: California published average $1,976 per year (Bankrate True Cost of Home Insurance 2025 state table (Bankrate report, August 25, 2025; full 50-state chart cross-checked against Bankrate's own press release figures); median home value from Ruby Home 2023 median home price summary, 2025, verified 2026-11-01), adjusted only by the simple band, roof, and deductible factors you selected above.

  • Factors that move real premiums up: older roof, coastal wind or hail exposure, higher replacement cost, lower deductible, prior claims.
  • Factors that move real premiums down: newer roof, higher deductible you can afford, mitigation, bundling where available.
  • Flood insurance is separate and is not included in this benchmark.

Add your renewal premium above to see it against this range here and in the printable summary.

Renewal above the benchmark? Shop it in this order →

Summary: my renewal vs benchmark

State
California
Dwelling band
$300k dwelling
Roof age
10-20 years
Deductible
$1,000 flat
Published state average
$1,976 per year, $300,000 dwelling basis (2025, verified 2026-11-01)
Benchmark range
$1,581 to $2,470 per year
My renewal
Not entered yet

Add your renewal premium above to see it against this range here and in the printable summary.

Benchmark range from published averages, not a quote. Flood insurance is separate and is not included. Saved on this device only.

Assumptions, printed

Worked example: the default view

The tool opens on California, a $300,000 dwelling band, a roof aged 10-20 years and a $1,000 flat deductible. Every factor is 1.0, so the center is simply the published California average of $1,976 per year, and the range renders as $1,581 to $2,470. Two lessons live in that plain example. First, even with every factor neutral, even at neutral factors the answer is a range more than $700 wide, because real premiums scatter. Second, the range only becomes useful when you change the inputs to match your home: move the dwelling band to $500,000 and the center rises by the 1.35 factor to about $2,668 before roof and deductible are even considered. Run your own combination, then compare the result with the state table and your state page before you judge any real quote.

What the benchmark cannot do

It cannot see your street, your exact rebuild cost, your claims history, or whether insurers are competing hard or quietly leaving your area. It will not tell you a quote is too high, only whether it sits inside or outside a published-average range for homes roughly like yours. If a real quote lands far outside the range, the useful question is which factor explains the distance, and our guides on roof age and material, deductible choice and lowering a premium without underinsuring take those factors in turn.

Common questions

Is the benchmark range a quote?

No. It is your state published average adjusted only by the simple factors printed on this page, widened into a range. It cannot see your address, your roof in person, your claims history or any insurer’s current appetite. Only an insurer or licensed agent can quote your home.

Where does the base figure come from?

Each state base is the published average in our checked-in data, for example California at $1,976 per year on a $300,000 dwelling basis (Bankrate True Cost of Home Insurance 2025 state table (Bankrate report, August 25, 2025; full 50-state chart cross-checked against Bankrate's own press release figures); median home value from Ruby Home 2023 median home price summary, 2025, verified 2026-11-01). The national average in the same report family is $2,470.

What do the adjustment factors assume?

Dwelling band: $300k at 1.0, $500k at 1.35, $750k at 1.7. Roof age: 0-10 years at 0.95, 10-20 at 1.0, 20+ at 1.2, unknown or older material at 1.35. Deductible: $1,000 flat at 1.0, $2,500 at 0.93, 1% of dwelling at 0.97, 2% at 0.9. The range shown is 80% to 125% of the adjusted center. These are simple published modeling factors for a benchmark, not an insurer rate filing.

Why does the range exclude flood?

Because flood insurance is a separate policy and a separate price. Including it silently would flatter the comparison for homes that need it and inflate it for homes that do not. See our guide on why flood insurance is separate.

Sources and verification

State averages: Bankrate True Cost of Home Insurance 2025 state table (Bankrate report, August 25, 2025), $300,000 dwelling basis, verified 2026-10-04. National average: Bankrate True Cost of Home Insurance report (press release, August 25, 2025), 2025. Adjustment factors are this site’s simple published benchmark model, printed above. Full method: Methodology. Limits of any benchmark: Disclaimer.